Commuted value: lump sum vs keeping a defined-benefit pension

Leaving a defined-benefit plan often comes with a one-time lump-sum offer: the commuted value. This page covers what that number is, where it can go, the CRA transfer cap, and why federal vs provincial jurisdiction matters.

The lump-sum present value of a defined-benefit pension

FSRA: the commuted value of a defined-benefit pension is the lump-sum value of all your future pension income today—the present value of the monthly pension you would otherwise receive for life after retirement. OSFI’s glossary: an immediate lump sum estimated to equal a future series of payments, calculated with Canadian Institute of Actuaries assumptions based on current market conditions. Official: FSRA: What is a Commuted Value? and OSFI Pension Members’ Guide. You may be entitled to transfer that amount when you terminate employment (or, in some cases, membership)—instead of leaving a deferred monthly pension in the plan. You are not always entitled to transfer. FSRA notes some members cannot; a plan may offer the option only if you terminate before a stated age (FSRA’s example is before age 55). Multi-employer plans can have special rules, including a permanently reduced commuted value based on funded level at termination.

Where a commuted value can go

If you elect the lump sum, you give up the lifetime pension and other plan benefits, including survivor benefits. FSRA: that decision is irreversible. When you are entitled, FSRA lists these Ontario destinations: another Canadian pension plan that will accept the transfer; a locked-in retirement account (LIRA / locked-in RRSP); a life income fund (LIF / locked-in RRIF) if you are at or near the plan’s earliest retirement age; and a life annuity from a Canadian insurer if the plan permits it. Federally regulated plans follow OSFI’s portability list under the Pension Benefits Standards Act, 1985: another pension plan willing to accept the funds; a locked-in RRSP, LIF, or restricted LIF (RLIF); or an immediate or deferred life annuity. OSFI also lists a cash refund if the pension benefit credit is not locked-in, and is explicit that a federal locked-in RRSP is not the same product as a provincial LIRA. Official: OSFI portability options. Unlocking exceptions exist, but the tests are statute-specific. See Unlock a LIRA.

CRA maximum transfer (Form T2151)

A defined-benefit RPP lump sum can be transferred directly to another RPP, an RRSP, a RRIF, a PRPP, or an SPP. You and the issuer complete Form T2151. For an RRSP transfer you must be 71 or younger at year-end. Official: CRA: RPP lump-sum payments and Form T2151. The Income Tax Act limits how much may move on a tax-deferred basis from a defined-benefit provision to a money-purchase RPP, RRSP, PRPP, SPP, or RRIF. CRA’s administrator guidance locates that cap in Regulation 8517; this page does not reproduce the formula. FSRA and OSFI: the excess above the tax limit is paid in cash, subject to withholding, and included in that year’s taxable income. You may be able to contribute that cash to a non-locked-in RRSP if you have room. CRA: the T4A reports the excess as pension income in boxes 018 and 108 (line 13000). If it was transferred into an RRSP, PRPP, or SPP, CRA treats it as a contribution that year—deductible on line 20800 only up to your RRSP deduction limit. Pension adjustments already reported on T4s during membership also reduce RRSP room (OSFI). Related: RRSP withdrawal tax, RRSP at 71, and RRSP to RRIF.

Federal vs provincial jurisdiction

Jurisdiction is the statute of the pension plan—not necessarily where you live now. OSFI regulates private plans for “included employment” under Parliament. Its members’ guide names banking, telecommunications, and inter-provincial transportation, plus plans in Yukon, the Northwest Territories, and Nunavut. Each province except Prince Edward Island has its own pension law for other employment. Unlocking rules, whether the locked-in vehicle is called a LIRA or a locked-in RRSP, and whether an RLIF exists, follow that statute. Ask the plan administrator which regulator applies.

Keep the deferred pension, or take the CV?

Qualitative factors FSRA and OSFI publish—no break-even age. A defined-benefit pension is designed to pay for life; in a LIRA or LIF you invest and must make the money last. FSRA lists inflation protection among features that can be expensive or impossible to replicate after a transfer—if the plan indexes at all. The plan may initially transfer only a portion of the commuted value; FSRA and OSFI say the remainder, plus interest, must generally follow within five years. OSFI: if the solvency ratio is below 1.00, the plan may not transfer the full credit when employment ends. Multi-employer plans can reduce the commuted value itself based on funded level. FSRA: as Bank of Canada bond yields rise, commuted values fall (and the reverse), all else equal. Survivor benefits stay with the plan only if you leave the pension in place; an annuity bought with the CV may not match the plan pension. CPP and OAS sit beside any workplace pension: how much CPP will I get and OAS amount.

See also: Unlocking a LIRA for financial hardship.

Model the workplace pension beside CPP and OAS

WisePlan Wealth is an on-device Canada retirement planner. Enter RRSP, TFSA, CPP, and OAS, then see how a locked-in stream vs a deferred pension-style income changes later cash flow. Free to start. No account. Data stays on the device.

iOSMacAndroid

This is general information, not financial, tax, or legal advice. Commuted-value options and the Income Tax Act transfer limit are set by pension standards legislation, the plan text, and the CRA, and can change. Confirm which regulator governs your plan before you elect a transfer.