This page is the excess and the 1% monthly tax—not FHSA basics or a Home Buyers’ Plan comparison. Related: FHSA, TFSA vs FHSA, FHSA vs Home Buyers’ Plan, TFSA overcontribution, RRSP overcontribution, and Home Buyers’ Plan.
CRA: you may have an excess FHSA amount if contributions plus RRSP-to-FHSA transfers in a year are more than your FHSA participation room for that year. Official wording: “Generally, you have to pay a tax of 1% per month on the highest excess FHSA amount in that month. You will continue to pay the monthly 1% tax until the excess FHSA amount is eliminated.” Searchers call it a 1% FHSA penalty; CRA calls it a tax. Income Tax Act section 207.021 (modified 2026-07-23) uses the same 1% of the highest excess that month. Official: What happens if you contribute or transfer too much to your FHSAs.
CRA’s TFSA excess pages use the same 1%-per-month-on-the-highest-excess structure. CRA’s FHSA pages do not publish a $2,000 “grace” or additional amount. The 1% continues until you remove amounts from your FHSAs, or new participation room on January 1 of the following year absorbs it. CRA’s 2025 examples still charge that 1% for the month the excess starts and every later month it remains, including the month you designate or withdraw it.
CRA’s Participating in your FHSAs page (2025 examples still published): participation room in the year you open your first FHSA is $8,000. That $8,000 is contributions and RRSP-to-FHSA transfers combined, across every FHSA you open. CRA’s definitions page: the lifetime FHSA limit = $40,000. The excess formula uses the lesser of $8,000 plus participation-room carryforward, and remaining lifetime room under that $40,000 cap. Exceeding either annual room or remaining lifetime room can create an excess. Official: Definitions for FHSAs.
Investment income inside the FHSA does not count toward participation room and does not, by itself, create an excess. Unused room can carry forward (CRA: lesser of $8,000 and unused amounts in its formula). An excess left at year-end reduces next year’s room; the 1% still applied for the months it sat. FHSA basics: FHSA. TFSA vs FHSA room: TFSA vs FHSA.
CRA lists four ways an excess can fall: a designated withdrawal, a designated transfer to an RRSP or RRIF, a taxable withdrawal, or amounts deemed received if the account loses FHSA status. A qualifying withdrawal to buy a home does not reduce or eliminate an excess. CRA warns that a qualifying withdrawal that includes an excess may leave you unable to clear it, so the 1% can continue. Home-purchase rules: FHSA vs Home Buyers’ Plan and Home Buyers’ Plan.
To designate, fill out Form RC727 and give it to your FHSA issuer. A designated amount cannot exceed the excess at that time. Contributions-only: designated withdrawal, not a designated transfer. RRSP-transfers-only: designated transfer, not a designated withdrawal. Mixed inflows can use both, each capped at that type of inflow minus prior designations. A designated withdrawal or designated transfer is not included as income. A designated transfer does not use unused RRSP deduction room. A taxable withdrawal is income. Your issuer reports designated transfers in T4FHSA box 36 and designated withdrawals in box 38. Official: Form RC727.
If you have an excess FHSA amount, you must file Form RC728, First Home Savings Account (FHSA) Return, and Form RC728-SCH-A, Schedule A, Excess FHSA Amounts. CRA: file the RC728 and pay by June 30 of the year following the calendar year in which the tax arose. If you do not file on time, CRA may assess from issuer records. If the excess arose due to a reasonable error and you are taking immediate steps to remove it, you may request a waiver on Form RC729. Official: FHSA taxes payable, assessments and reassessments, Form RC728, and Form RC728-SCH-A.
CRA’s excess-TFSA examples page: the TFSA 1% tax is similar to the RRSP excess tax “except that in the case of a TFSA, there is no $2,000 ‘grace’ amount.” The RRSP rule is unused contributions more than your deduction limit plus $2,000. CRA’s FHSA excess pages do not publish a $2,000 additional amount. The 1% is on the excess FHSA amount from the first dollar. Details: TFSA overcontribution and RRSP overcontribution. Official: Examples – Tax payable on excess TFSA amount and Excess Contributions (RRSP).
WisePlan Wealth is an on-device Canada retirement planner. Enter FHSA, TFSA, and RRSP balances beside CPP and OAS. Free to start. No account. Data stays on-device.
This is general information, not financial, tax, investment, legal, or accounting advice. FHSA room and excess-tax rules are set by the CRA and can change. Confirm current rules, your participation room, and any amount owing on Canada.ca, in your CRA account, or with a qualified professional.