Short answer: The order you take money out matters as much as how much you saved. The same $7,500 a month goes from 17% to 96% just by drawing from every account in a tax-smart way and easing off a little later on.
A sample couple in Regina, Saskatchewan, run in the WisePlan Wealth app. All amounts are after tax, in today's dollars.
Rick is 60 and has just retired from his job as a provincial IT analyst in Regina. Renee is 57 and plans to keep working as a claims adjuster at a Crown corporation until she's 60, in mid-2029. Together they've saved about $900,000. Their question: which money do they use first, and how much can they spend once they're both retired?
Here's what they have: Rick's workplace pension savings and RRSP come to $627,300. Renee's RRSP is $72,100. Their TFSAs are $88,000 and $71,500, and they have $41,000 in a non-registered account. Renee is saving about $1,200 a month until she stops, and her workplace pension pays $1,950 a month from 60, rising with inflation. CPP (about $1,290 and $1,118 a month) and OAS (about $762.50 each) start at 65.
So we ran it. The plan runs to age 95, and all spending is after tax in today's dollars. The plan gets tested against many historical market runs, the good starts and the bad ones.
Step 1: Spend the same amount every year, no matter what. $7,500 a month, flat, for life, taking money out the simple way. It holds up in only 17% of historical markets, and the money runs out about a year early even in an average market.
Step 2: Same starting amount, but a more flexible plan. They spend $7,500 a month in the earlier years, $7,250 from 75 to 84, and $7,000 after that, with withdrawals timed to keep tax low. To find that $7,500, we pushed spending as high as the plan allows ($7,900, which holds up in only 51% of markets), then brought it down until the plan held up in more than 90%.
That plan holds up in 96% of historical markets, with about $526,000 left at 95 in the base case.
In 2029, their first year both retired, they'd have about $7,588 a month before tax: Renee's $1,950 pension, $2,706 from non-registered savings, $1,804 from the RRSPs and $1,128 from the TFSAs. Only about $88 goes to tax, which leaves $7,500.
Why the flexible plan holds up better: the simple way pays for everything from the TFSAs first, so the tax-free cushion is gone in the first couple of years and the RRSPs have to carry everything later, on top of CPP and OAS. The flexible plan takes a little from every account from the start, while their income is low and before CPP and OAS begin, and eases spending off a bit at 75 and 85.
The takeaway: the order you take money out matters as much as how much you saved. The same $7,500 a month goes from 17% to 96% just by drawing from every account in a tax-smart way and easing off a little later on.


The free calculators above each answer one piece. For the full picture, with how much you can safely spend, which account to draw from first and when to start CPP and OAS, download WisePlan Wealth.
This couple is an example, not real people. The numbers come from a real run of the WisePlan Wealth app with its default return and inflation assumptions. This is an example, not advice, and your numbers will be different.