Retirement stories › USA

Retiring at 60, before Social Security, in Michigan

Short answer: Yes, they can stop in 2030. About $990,000 and three and a half more years of saving, with no pension, support about $6,550 a month ($78,600 a year) after tax from 60 and 58, seven years before Social Security, but only when the money comes out in a tax-smart order. Spending the same amount flat, the simple way, holds up in only 78% of markets.

A sample couple in Lansing, Michigan, run in the WisePlan Wealth app. All amounts are after tax, in today's dollars.

Lance and Lori have about $990,000 saved and no workplace pension. They both want to stop working in mid-2030, when Lance is 60 and Lori is 58, seven years before Lance's Social Security starts. Instead of picking a budget and hoping it works, we looked for the most they can actually afford to spend.

The setup

See the answer, year by year

Loading the interactive plan…

Before: same spending every year, simple withdrawals

$6,550/mo ($78,600/yr) after tax, flat for life → holds up in only 78% of historical markets, with about $382,000 left at 95 in an average market.

After: flexible plan, tax-smart withdrawals

Holds up in 91% of historical markets, with about $972,000 left at 95 in an average market.

How we got there: the most the plan allows is $7,250/mo, but that holds up in only 51% of markets. We brought it down until it cleared 90% at $6,550.

First year after they stop (2030): about $6,878/mo before tax: $4,952 from the 401(k)s, $1,238 from the taxable account and $688 from the Roth IRAs. About $328 goes to tax, which leaves $6,550.

Why the flexible plan holds up better: The simple way pays for everything from the Roth IRAs first (the full $6,550 a month in 2030), so the 401(k)s sit and grow and come out later on top of Social Security and required withdrawals, at a higher tax rate. With no pension, they have seven low-income years before Lance's Social Security starts at 67, and nine before Lori's. The flexible plan uses those years to draw from the 401(k)s and the taxable account at a low tax rate, leaves most of the Roth IRAs growing tax-free, and eases spending down a bit at 75 and 85.

Takeaway: Yes, they can stop in 2030. About $990,000 and three and a half more years of saving, with no pension, support about $6,550 a month ($78,600 a year) after tax from 60 and 58, seven years before Social Security, but only when the money comes out in a tax-smart order. Spending the same amount flat, the simple way, holds up in only 78% of markets.

The before and after charts

Before plan chart for Lansing, Michigan: monthly spending, how often the plan holds up, cash flow and savings over time
Before: same spending every year, simple withdrawals.
After plan chart for Lansing, Michigan: monthly spending, how often the plan holds up, cash flow and savings over time
After: flexible plan with tax-smart withdrawals.

Try the free calculators

More retirement stories

Run your own numbers

The free calculators above each answer one piece. For the full picture, with how much you can safely spend, which account to draw from first and when to start Social Security, download WisePlan Wealth.

iOSMacAndroid

This couple is an example, not real people. The numbers come from a real run of the WisePlan Wealth app with its default return and inflation assumptions. This is an example, not advice, and your numbers will be different.