Does the 4% rule work in Canada and the US? Tested on real market history
Short answer
Mostly, but not always. We tested a flat 4% (4% of your savings in year one, then the same amount plus inflation) on every 30-year period of real US market history from 1928 to 2025. With half stocks and half bonds it lasted in 64 of 69 periods. It ran out early for retirements that started in 1964, 1965, 1966, 1968, 1969. The highest flat rate that lasted every time was 3.66%.
- Canada and the US
- CPP and OAS, or Social Security, cover part of your spending, so you need less from savings. Test yours below.
- Spend more early
- Planning to spend less in your 70s and 80s lets you start higher. The calculator finds the most you can spend in your Go-Go, Slo-Go and No-Go years.
WisePlan Wealth is an on-device retirement spending planner for Canada and the United States (private, no account). It does not give advice or file taxes.
Calculator: test the 4% rule on real market history
Runs in your browser. Nothing is saved or sent.
See your whole plan: the most you can spend each month and whether your net worth lastsPast markets, not a forecast. Today’s dollars, before tax and fees. Illustration only, not financial, tax or investment advice.
Our results: how often each rate lasted 30 years
| Flat rate | 40% stocks | 50% stocks | 60% stocks |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3% | 69 of 69 | 69 of 69 | 69 of 69 |
| 3.5% | 69 of 69 | 69 of 69 | 69 of 69 |
| 3.9% | 62 of 69 | 65 of 69 | 66 of 69 |
| 4% | 62 of 69 | 64 of 69 | 65 of 69 |
| 4.5% | 49 of 69 | 57 of 69 | 58 of 69 |
| 5% | 41 of 69 | 46 of 69 | 50 of 69 |
| Highest rate that lasted every time | 3.58% | 3.66% | 3.73% |
69 historical 30-year periods, retirements starting 1928 to 1996. Computed by WisePlan Wealth with the same code as the calculator above (our own historical backtest, not the app’s Monte Carlo engine), November 13, 2026.
| $1,000,000 at 65, half stocks, to 95 | Flat, every month | Go-Go / Slo-Go / No-Go (10% less at 75 and 85) |
|---|---|---|
| No government benefits | $3,055 | $3,319 / $2,987 / $2,688 |
| Canada: CPP + OAS from 65 ($1,620.84 a month) | $4,676 | $5,080 / $4,572 / $4,114 |
| US: Social Security from 67 ($2,092.17 a month) | $4,989 | $5,419 / $4,877 / $4,389 |
Most you could spend each month, in today’s dollars and including benefits, without running out in any of the 69 periods. Benefit amounts: average CPP at 65 (July 2026) plus full OAS for ages 65 to 74 (October to December 2026) from Canada.ca; average retired-worker Social Security benefit (October 2026) from SSA. Canadian dollars for the Canada row and US dollars for the US row, run on the same US market history.
How this is calculated
- Market history: S&P 500 total returns (dividends included) and 10-year US Treasury bond total returns for each year from 1928 to 2025, from Aswath Damodaran at NYU Stern. Inflation: US consumer prices (CPI-U), December to December, from the US Bureau of Labor Statistics.
- Everything is in today’s dollars. Each year the withdrawal comes out at the start of the year, and the rest earns that year’s after-inflation return on your stock and bond mix, rebalanced once a year.
- Every possible start year is tested: a 30-year plan has 69 starting years, 1928 to 1996. A period “lasts” if every withdrawal is paid in full.
- Government benefits are paid from the age you choose and keep pace with inflation, as CPP, OAS and Social Security do. They reduce what you take from savings. The OAS recovery tax (clawback), income tax and fees are not included.
- Go-Go, Slo-Go and No-Go: you spend your Go-Go amount until 74, a set percent less from 75, and that percent less again from 85. The ages match the WisePlan app’s defaults; the percent is your choice. The answer is the highest Go-Go amount that never ran out.
- Why US data for Canada: a long Canadian return series is not freely published. Canadian stocks, bonds and inflation took a different path, so a Canadian portfolio would give somewhat different results.
Bengen’s 4% vs our test vs Morningstar’s 3.9%
Bengen’s 1994 study used US data from 1926 to 1992 with medium-term government bonds; there, a 4% start never lasted less than 33 years. Our test runs to 2025 with 10-year Treasuries; with half stocks, the worst start (1966) lasted 24 years. Morningstar’s research for 2026 retirees uses forecasts instead of history and puts the safe starting rate at 3.9% (30 years, 90% chance of money left, 30% to 50% in stocks), and up to 5.7% for people willing to change their spending from year to year.
RRIF minimums and US RMDs
In Canada, a RRIF has a minimum yearly withdrawal set by CRA. Up to age 70 it is 1 divided by (90 minus your age): exactly 4% at 65. From 71 CRA’s table applies: 5.28% at 71, 6.82% at 80, 8.51% at 85 and 20% from 95. A RRIF minimum is what must come out, not what you must spend: money you don’t need can go to a TFSA if you have room. In the US, required minimum distributions start at 73; the IRS Uniform Lifetime Table divisor at 73 is 26.5, about 3.77% of the balance. See RRIF minimum withdrawals.
Sources
- Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern, Historical Returns on Stocks, Bonds and Bills (S&P 500 with dividends and 10-year Treasury bond returns, 1928 to 2025; updated January 2026)
- US Bureau of Labor Statistics, CPI-U all items, series CUUR0000SA0 (December values, 1927 to 2025)
- William Bengen, “Determining Withdrawal Rates Using Historical Data,” Journal of Financial Planning, October 1994 (Financial Planning Association reprint)
- Morningstar, What’s a Safe Retirement Withdrawal Rate for 2026? (December 3, 2025; 3.9% base case, up to 5.7% with flexible spending)
- CRA, Chart: prescribed factors (RRIF minimums)
- IRS, Publication 590-B (Uniform Lifetime Table; RMDs from 73)
- Canada.ca, CPP: how much you could receive (average at 65, July 2026: $858.34) and OAS payment amounts (October to December 2026, ages 65 to 74: $762.50)
- SSA, Monthly Statistical Snapshot, October 2026 (average retired-worker benefit: $2,092.17)
FAQ
- Does the 4% rule work in Canada?
- Partly. We ran a flat 4% through 69 US market periods from 1928 to 2025 (Canada has no free long public return series, so we use US history for both countries). With half stocks, it lasted 30 years in 64 of 69. It ran out early for retirements that started in 1964, 1965, 1966, 1968, 1969. CPP and OAS do not change that result, because the 4% rule covers only your savings, but they raise how much you can spend in total.
- Is 4% still a safe withdrawal rate in 2026?
- Morningstar’s research for people retiring in 2026 puts the highest safe starting rate at 3.9% for a 30-year retirement with a 90% chance of money left, using its forecasts rather than history. In our own historical test, the highest flat rate that lasted every 30-year period with half stocks was 3.66%.
- What did Bengen actually find?
- William Bengen’s 1994 paper used US returns from 1926 to 1992 and a 50/50 mix of large-company stocks and medium-term government bonds. In his data a 4% start never ran out in less than 33 years. Our test uses 10-year Treasury returns, a different inflation series and data through 2025, so its results differ: with half stocks, 4% ran out early in 5 of 69 periods.
- How do CPP, OAS or Social Security change the answer?
- They pay part of your spending, so you take less from savings. In our test, $1,000,000 at 65 with half stocks supported $3,055 a month with no benefits, $4,676 with average CPP plus full OAS from 65, and $4,989 with the average Social Security retirement benefit from 67, lasting to 95 in every historical period.
- What are Go-Go, Slo-Go and No-Go years?
- Many retirees spend more in their active early years (Go-Go), less in their 70s (Slo-Go) and less again later (No-Go). If you plan to spend 10% less from 75 and 10% less again from 85, the same $1,000,000 could start at $3,319 a month with no benefits instead of $3,055, in our test.
- Is the RRIF minimum the same as the 4% rule?
- No. The RRIF minimum is a CRA rule for how much must come out each year. At 65 it is exactly 4% (1 divided by 90 minus your age), then it rises: 5.28% at 71, 6.82% at 80 and 20% from 95. You can take more, and you do not have to spend what you withdraw. In the US, required minimum distributions start at 73 with an IRS divisor of 26.5, about 3.77%.
Full guide
What the 4% rule actually says
Take 4% of your savings in your first year of retirement. After that, ignore the percent: raise the dollar amount each year with inflation. On $1,000,000 that is $40,000 in year one. It comes from William Bengen’s 1994 study of the hardest US starting years, not from an average.
Does it work in Canada?
The rule is about savings only, so the math is the same in Canada and the United States. What differs is the rest of your income. CPP and OAS start as early as 60 and 65, and Social Security as early as 62. Those payments rise with inflation and cover part of your spending, so the savings you need for the same lifestyle is smaller. Canada also forces RRIF withdrawals from 72 (after converting by the end of the year you turn 71), and OAS can be clawed back at higher incomes; see the OAS calculator.
When 4% failed
In our test with half stocks, every 4% failure started between 1964 and 1969. Those retirees met a weak stock market in the 1970s together with high inflation, which raised their inflation-adjusted withdrawals while their savings fell. This is sequence of returns risk: the order of returns matters more than the average.
Spend more when you are most active
Many people spend more in their active early years and less later. Planning for that lets you start higher than a flat rate. WisePlan Wealth finds the most you can afford to spend each month across your Go-Go, Slo-Go and No-Go years, using your RRSP, TFSA, 401(k), IRA and other savings plus CPP and OAS or Social Security, and shows whether your net worth lasts for the whole of retirement. Get WisePlan Wealth. Free to start. No account. Data stays on your device.
Related guides
- How much can I spend in retirement? (Canada)
- Sequence of returns risk
- RRIF minimum withdrawals
- How much OAS will I get? (calculator)
- How retirement apps test a plan against many possible markets
- Retirement income gap (US)
This is general information, not financial, tax or investment advice. Past market returns do not predict future returns. Page dated November 13, 2026.